I was at my monthly Java (TM) user group meeting tonight, and during the pre-meeting discussion our president Burr Sutter asked a question he usually asks: "So, anybody working on anything exciting?" This typically is taken as "does anyone have a really cool Java (TM) project that they are working on right now that would be neat for us to hear about?"
I usually sit there, not saying anything. But tonight, nobody had anything much, and I finally spoke up about free runtimes for Java (TM). I told them that great progress is being made in the free runtimes for Java (TM) arena, particularly in GNU Classpath and Kaffe. After my update, Burr asked a very good question: "Why would you work on a free, open runtime for Java (TM) programming language?" My answer follows.
You would work on it in order to have a free alternative to a platform governed by the SCSL.
You work on a free runtime for Java (TM) because a free alternative would be better than what we have now; a closely-guarded and largely ingrown platform. You work on improving a free alternative because you are free to participate without that project demanding (via a legally-binding license) that you can only work with them from here on out, and that nothing you learn while devoting your time and energy to them (without compensation) can be used elsewhere. If you do share it elsewhere, and that project finds out, their legal team will make an example out of your ass.
You prefer a free alternative runtime for the same reason that you prefer the free alternatives to the non-free frameworks and platforms available for use on Java(TM). Why is Hibernate so popular? Why is Spring so popular? Why is EJB not? Because innovation by committee, while better than a ruthless, unaccountable corporate entity concerned solely with its own betterment, is still not as good as free, open cooperation and collaboration.
Is this idea so new? Don't we try to teach kids that sharing and honesty is the Right Thing (TM) to do? I will probably flesh this out as an article at some point, but I wanted to get something written down tonight, while it's still fresh in my mind.